There is a good chance that this post contains affiliate links. If you click on any of these links, I might earn a small commission at no extra cost to you (which I really appreciate, thank you!) The full disclosure policy can be found here.

Maui vs. Kauai

Maui vs. Kauai, which island is better for a Hawaii vacation or honeymoon? One of the questions that I am asked most often is, “Which Hawaii island is best?” Well, the truth is that there isn’t really an answer to that question. I have talked about which Hawaii island is best for honeymoons and which Hawaii island is best for families. 

I have noticed that, especially with honeymoons, it often comes down to Maui vs. Kauai.

For this blog post, I decided to go over Maui vs. Kauai in-depth and help you decide where you want to spend time on your Hawaii vacation.

Before we get started, let me introduce myself. My name is Amy, and I’m a Hawaii Travel Agent. I’m one of the top travel agents for Hawaii, and creating fantastic custom trips in Hawaii is my passion! Contact me today to help plan and book your Hawaii vacation.

Don’t miss my itineraries for Hawaii if you want insider tips for your vacation, but don’t need to work with a Hawaii Travel Agent.

DO I NEED A RENTAL CAR in Maui or Kauai?

YES! You definitely need a car, whether you choose a Maui vacation or a Kauai vacation. Public transportation is limited, and you’ll want to get out and explore. You’ll find the best prices anywhere at Discount Hawaii Car Rental. 

How many Hawaii islands can you visit in one week?

You aren’t going to like my answer, because it’s one. If you only have one week in Hawaii, I would advise visiting only one island.  While you certainly can visit more than one island in a week, I wouldn’t recommend it.

Each island in Hawaii is so diverse. You really need to spend several days on the island to truly appreciate it. 

Getting to Maui vs. Kauai

Many travelers (wrongly) assume that they will have to fly into Honolulu and then fly to the smaller islands. Fortunately, there are daily flights to Kahului (Maui) and Lihue (Kauai) from most major cities.

Traveling to Hawaii isn’t fun, but you can check out my post on how to survive the flight to Hawaii. Just remember, it will be worth it once you arrive!

You can read more about why you need a rental car in Hawaii ,but suffice to say, you’ll need one on either island. 

So as you can see, it’s pretty easy to get to Maui or Kauai. You’ll need a rental car on both islands, so neither one comes out ahead in this category. 

Weather in Maui vs. Kauai

The weather is one category that really makes these two destinations different. Maui’s primary resort areas (the west side and the south side) are warm and sunny year-round. The only time you’ll need a jacket in Maui is if you venture up to Haleakala, which I recommend doing! You can read my guide to Haleakala Sunrise in Maui to learn more.

Moving on to Kauai, the main resort area in Kauai is on the south side, but there is a smaller resort area on the north side. The two areas are quite different. The south shore is almost always sunny, but the north shore does get more rain. However, the rainfall makes for some of Hanalei and Prineville’s most spectacular scenery on Kauai’s North Shore. 

Rainfall tends to be brief throughout Hawaii, even on the North Shore, so it shouldn’t interfere with your trip. Just be prepared to put the top back on your Jeep or convertible at a moment’s notice!

It can be a little cooler on Kauai during the winter, but probably not anything you’ll notice. Hawaii has comfortable temperatures year-round, no matter which island you visit.

So, does Maui or Kauai have better weather? Neither! They both have varying weather, and you’ll always find a warm, sunny beach no matter which island you’re on.

The scenery on Maui and Kauai

This is where it gets interesting and maybe controversial. Both Kauai and Maui offer beautiful coastlines, tropical jungles, and stunning mountains. 

The difference in the scenery on Maui is that it’s far more accessible on Kauai. Is it as beautiful as the scenery on Kauai? Well, in my opinion, no. There’s a reason that Jurassic Park was filmed on Kauai! It’s not that Maui isn’t beautiful, but you really have to see Kauai to fully appreciate it.

Although, as I said, to see Kauai, you have to get creative. I highly recommend a Kauai helicopter tour to see the beauty of the island truly. The best helicopter tours in Kauai has all my favorites. 

I took this on my own Kauai helicopter tour. Check out my review.

Kauai has something very unique to the island – navigable rivers! You can kayak on the Wailua River and the Hule‘ia River on Kauai.

Maui has the incredible Road to Hana, which is another must-do on the island. 

Since we are comparing the two islands, I give Kauai a slight advantage over Maui in the scenery category. 

Activities on Kauai and Maui

If you love spending time outdoors, you can’t go wrong with Maui or Kauai. The list of things to do is abundant, including hiking, snorkeling, golfing, boating, and surfing.

Snorkeling is good on Kauai, but Maui has some of the best places to snorkel in Hawaii. Some require a boat tour like Molokini Crater, but some of the best spots can be accessed by land. Black Rock is a great snorkeling spot on Maui and near some of the best resorts. 

Some of Kauai’s best snorkeling spots, such as Tunnels Beach, can be more difficult during the winter months due to rough water.

While Maui has some great hikes, Kauai definitely wins for the best hikes in Hawaii. The epic Kalalau Trail requires some advanced planning, but other ridge trails, such as the Awa’awapuhi Trail, can be hiked any time. Check out 10 Reservations you need to make before going to Hawaii to learn what needs to be booked in advance. 

You can also check out the 7 best hikes on Kauai for more epic Kauai hikes.

If you like breweries, wineries, and distilleries, you can find them all on Maui. Kauai also has a rum distillery and a brewery. There isn’t a clear winner for activities on Maui vs. Kauai. If hiking is #1 on your to-do list, Kauai might be right for you. If snorkeling is your #1 priority, you can’t go wrong on Maui. 

The beaches on Maui and Kauai

When it comes to the best beaches in Hawaii, Maui always comes out on top. Maui has more swimmable beaches than Kauai in yellow, black, and red sand. Although the beaches on Maui tend to be narrow, there are plenty of them. Makena Beach (also called Big Beach) is one of the most popular on the island. 

While the water in Kauai can be rough (especially in the winter), you will still find beautiful beaches all over the island. The beaches of Kauai are also often considerably larger than the beaches on Maui.

If you make your way out to Polihale State Park, you’ll find miles of beach with very few people around, if any. 

Which is better, Maui or Kauai?

While Maui and Kauai have a lot of similarities, they’re also very different. Kauai is a bit more laid back and less developed. That can be good or bad depending on what you’re looking for. 

For some visitors, Maui offers the best of both worlds by having more upscale shops and chain restaurants but lacking Oahu’s chaos and traffic. 

Wildlife on Maui and Kauai

You’ll see plenty of wildlife, such as green sea turtles and tropical fish, on both islands. It’s also worth noting that Maui has some of the best humpback whale sightings in Hawaii. I’ve seen whales in Kauai as well, but you typically see more of them on Maui.

Alternatively, you’re much more likely to see the endangered monk seal on Kauai. 

Island hopping on Maui and Kauai

I don’t recommend island hopping for one day, as the flights and airport time will eat up a lot of your day. That said, if you decide to do it, the flights themselves are only about 45 minutes. 

On Maui, it’s easy to make a day trip to Molokai or Lanai. The only ferries currently operating in Hawaii are on Maui and go to Lanai and Molokai. Of course, you can also fly on Hawaiian, Southwest, or Mokulele Airlines.

There are no ferries on Kauai, but you can spend a day snorkeling the forbidden isle of Ni’ihau. This is the only way to access the private island, even though you technically do not go ashore. 

Have you decided which island you’d like to visit? If not, maybe a look at some of my favorite resorts will help. 

The best resort on Maui for honeymoons

Although Maui has quite a selection of honeymoon resorts, my favorite is the Andaz Maui at Wailea. The Andaz Maui has an adults-only pool, which is great for honeymoon couples. Although the Andaz is not adults-only, you’ll find fewer children here, as there aren’t many amenities for families. I have a review here: Andaz Maui at Wailea Resort Review.

If you’re looking for a truly adults-only resort, Hotel Wailea is one of the few adults-only resorts in Hawaii. The Hotel Wailea is also the only Relais & Châteaux hotel in Hawaii. This boutique hotel has only 72 one-bedroom suites and is set on three tropical acres. 

The best resort on Maui for families

Fairmont Kea Lani

This upscale resort is considered one of the best family-friendly resorts in Maui. You can stay in a two or 3-bedroom villa if you have a larger family or extended family. Fairmont Kea Lani also offers 1-bedroom suites available for smaller families.

The pool is always a big hit for kids, and the restaurants are always a big hit for everyone! If you don’t want to dine onsite, the best restaurants in Maui are located in Wailea, very close to the Fairmont Kea Lani.

Hyatt Regency Maui Resort

One of the best resorts in Maui at a slightly lower price point is the Hyatt Regency Maui. Fun fact, I book this resort more than any other resort in Hawaii, and my clients love it! There are also penguins that live here! Of course, I have a full review: Hyatt Regency Maui Review.

The best resort on Kauai for honeymoons

Located on Poipu Beach, the Ko’a Kea Hotel and Resort is one of the island’s highest-rated resorts. If you’re looking for an intimate and romantic oceanfront boutique resort, I highly recommend the Ko’a Kea. This resort is perfect for honeymoons or anniversaries.

One resort that is fantastic for families AND honeymooners is the Grand Hyatt Kauai. I recommend this resort for anyone, as long as a very large (the third largest in Hawaii) resort is your style! Full review here: Grand Hyatt Kauai Review.

The best resort on Kauai for families

If the Grand Hyatt is outside of your budget, Koloa Landing Resort has the perfect mix of resort amenities and large luxury villas. The pools are some of the best on the island. While it is not beachfront, you can quickly walk to shops or the beach.

I have a review here: Koloa Landing Resort Review.

Kauai vs. Maui

I hope that this post helped you decide if you would rather visit Maui, Kauai, or both!

I am a Hawaii Travel Agent, and that is what I do. While I specialize in honeymoons and romantic travel, I am available for any Hawaii trip. I often work with groups and families, and destination weddings too! Reach out as soon as possible for the best availability, as I only take on a select number of monthly clients. You can contact me to learn more.

For more Hawaii travel tips, check out some of my most popular blog posts:

• The 7 Best Things to do in Maui
• 10 best adventure activities on Kauai
• 7 day Kauai Itinerary
• 100 things to do in Hawaii
• 10 things you NEED to know before going to Hawaii

Dreaming of Hawaii, but not ready to travel just yet? Sign up for my newsletter! You will receive a weekly email with travel tips, Hawaii news, and more. If you love these posts and want to support my blog but aren’t prepared to travel yet, you can buy me a coffee to show your support. I ❤️ coffee!

Pin it for later: